Control Charts - Methods

1) Selecting the correct control chart.
There are many types of control chart. The type of data being collected will determine the chart to used. Use this diagram to select the correct chart for the situation.

All of the various control charts are similar in appearance and structure.

Certain predetermined patterns inside the
control limits also indicate special causes


2) Control charts for Variables
The charts for variables described in these guidelines are;

  • Mean and range ( x-bar & R ) preferred for most manual applications.
  • Median and range ( x-tilda & R ) the most simple.
These charts are used in pairs, one to monitor process and the other to monitor variability.


2.1) Sample selection

  • A sample size of 5 has been found to give reliable results, and is commonly used for x-bar & R and x-tilda & R charts. Sample sizes must stay consistent for any one chart. 20 - 25 groups of samples are required before calculating control limits and statistics.
  • Samples should be taken periodically at regular intervals to provide a picture that relates to all aspects of the process. To prevent 'regularity' introducing a bias to the data collected, the collection frequency could be about, every 200 produced, about every hour or four times a shift or so on.
  • Samples should capture the effects of process disturbances such as start up, tool changes, shut down and shift changes.
  • The units in a sample should have been produced consecutively. Samples of consecutive units will give a better idea of process disturbances than samples chosen randomly.

  • 2.2) Special circumstances

    • The purpose of charting is to develop a picture of process variability and setting. It is wise to do this as quickly, and economically as possible. ( The guide lines for sample selection allow room to manoeuvre.) For the first chart, 125 consecutive units might be taken, and treated as if they were 25 samples of 5.
    • The data might reflect a single run with no disturbances, such as tool changes, start ups or stops. The resulting chart probably not reflect the true behaviour of the process, but it will be better than no chart at all, and give a starting point for identifying process improvements and special causes which occur.
    • As time passes and more charts are generated, the picture will become clearer, and problems will be more easily identified.


    2.3) Process changes

    • Generally, process changes will show clearly on a chart. When ever there is a change, the chart control lines will need to be recalculated.
    • Recalculating of controls should be recalculated once the data from 20 samples has been collected following the change.


    3) Mean and Range Chart ( x-bar & R )

    • Raw data record. The measurements of each unit in the sample are recorded.


    • The following statistics are calculated from the measurements;
      • Sample Mean x-bar The sum of the individual values, divided by the sample size.
      • Sample Range R The difference between the largest and smallest values in the sample.
    • Parameter record. Two parameters are calculated from the statistics, and drawn on the chart as broken horizontal lines. ( ref. figures 2 & 3 )
      • Process Mean x-bar The sum of all the sample means divided by the total number of samples.
      • Mean Range R The sum of all the sample ranges divided by the total number of samples.
    • Figure 2
      A 'mean' control chart, with control lines based on ranges

      Figure 3
      A 'range' control chart

    • Four control lines are calculated from the parameters using the formulae shown in Figures 2 and 3 and drawn on the chart as solid horizontal lines. If the lower control line on the range control chart is a negative number, set the LCL to zero. ( Ref. figure 5 for formulae constants ).

    4) Median and Range Chart ( x-tilda & R )

    Figure 4

    • The ranges graph is the same as the x-bar & R chart. ( see Figure 3 )
    • The medians graph will detect changes in the process mean, but will not estimate the process mean.
    • When the actual value of the mean is important, more useful information will be obtained from x-bar & R charts.

    The differences between the x-bar chart and the x-tilda chart

    • Measurements of the units in a sample are recorded only as plots in a vertical line on the chart ( Figure 4 ) rather than written numbers.
    • The median ( or middle ) value for each sample is highlighted on the chart, if there an even number of units in the sample, the highlight is placed between the two middle values. Lines are then drawn to join the medians. This is instead of calculating, plotting and joining the means, as on a x-tilda chart.
    • Control lines are calculated from x-tilda-bar ( the mean of the sample medians ) and R, using the formula shown in Figure 4. The constants A, D and D depend on the size of the sample ( see Constant Table, Figure 5 ). NOTE: A is used for medians charts and A for means charts.
    • Control lines for medians are about 25% further apart than those for means, but this does not have any practical significance.

    Figure 5
    Table of Constants

    The data shown is for the x-bar & R and x-tilda & R charts.

    Sample Size
    n
    A2 ~
    A2
    D3 D4
    21.8801.88003.267
    31.0231.18702.574
    40.7290.79602.282
    50.5770.69102.114
    60.4930.54802.004
    70.4190.5080.0761.924
    80.3730.43301361.864
    90.3370.4120.1841.816
    100.3080.3620.2231.77
    110.285 0.2561.744
    120.266 0.2831.717
    130.249 0.3071.693
    140.235 0.3281.672
    150.223 0.3471.635
    160.121 0.3631.637
    170.203 0.3781.622
    180.194 0.3911.608
    190.187 0.4031.597
    200.180 0.4151.585
    210.173 0.4251.575
    220.167 0.4341.566
    230.162 0.4431.557
    240.157 0.4511.548
    250.153 0.4591.541